When you request a quote for sunflower oil, cashew nuts, sugar or any other bulk agricultural commodity, the seller will almost always ask which Incoterm you want. For many buyers — especially those placing their first order from Africa — the choice between FOB and CIF can feel unclear. Both are standard international trade terms, but they carry very different implications for cost, risk and control of your shipment.
This guide explains both terms in plain language, walks through a real-world cost comparison for a 20-foot container, and helps you decide which term makes sense for your business.
What Are Incoterms?
Incoterms (International Commercial Terms) are a set of standardised trade terms published by the International Chamber of Commerce (ICC) that define exactly where the seller's obligations end and the buyer's begin. They determine who is responsible for freight costs, marine insurance, customs documentation and — critically — who bears the risk of loss or damage at each stage of the journey.
The current version, Incoterms 2020, contains eleven terms. For bulk agricultural shipments by sea, FOB and CIF are by far the most commonly used.
FOB — Free On Board
Definition: The seller's responsibility ends once the goods are loaded onto the vessel at the named port of shipment. The buyer takes risk and cost from that point forward.
In practice: Under FOB Dar es Salaam, Golden Seed Export delivers the goods, clears export customs, and loads the container onto the ship at Dar es Salaam port. From the moment the goods cross the ship's rail, the buyer is responsible for the ocean freight, marine insurance and any costs at the destination port.
What the seller covers under FOB
- All costs to transport goods to the named port
- Export customs clearance, duties and fees
- Port handling charges at the loading port
- Loading the container onto the vessel
- All export documentation (commercial invoice, packing list, certificate of origin, phytosanitary certificate)
What the buyer covers under FOB
- Ocean freight from the loading port to the discharge port
- Marine cargo insurance (the buyer's choice whether to insure)
- Destination port charges, unloading, terminal handling
- Import customs clearance, duties and taxes at destination
- Inland delivery from the discharge port to the final destination
CIF — Cost, Insurance and Freight
Definition: The seller pays for the ocean freight and purchases marine insurance on the buyer's behalf. The risk transfers to the buyer once the goods are loaded onto the vessel — the same point as FOB — but the seller has already arranged and paid for the insurance that covers that risk in transit.
In practice: Under CIF Rotterdam, Golden Seed Export covers the ocean freight to Rotterdam and takes out a minimum cargo insurance policy (Institute Cargo Clauses C). The buyer takes possession of the goods at the discharge port and handles import clearance and inland delivery from there.
What the seller covers under CIF
- Everything covered under FOB, plus:
- Ocean freight from loading port to named destination port
- Minimum marine cargo insurance (ICC Clause C)
What the buyer covers under CIF
- Destination port charges, unloading, terminal handling
- Import customs clearance, duties and taxes
- Inland delivery from the discharge port
- Additional cargo insurance beyond the minimum (if required)
The Key Difference: Risk vs Convenience
A common misconception is that CIF is safer for the buyer because the seller arranges insurance. In fact, the risk transfer point is identical under both FOB and CIF — the moment the goods are loaded onto the vessel. Under CIF, the buyer bears the risk in transit but the seller has purchased the minimum insurance on the buyer's behalf.
| Aspect | FOB | CIF |
|---|---|---|
| Ocean freight paid by | Buyer | Seller |
| Marine insurance paid by | Buyer (optional) | Seller (minimum ICC-C) |
| Risk transfers at | Loading onto vessel | Loading onto vessel |
| Freight forwarder chosen by | Buyer | Seller |
| Freight costs transparent to | Buyer (full visibility) | Seller (buyer sees only CIF price) |
| Insurance coverage level | Buyer's choice | Minimum (ICC-C) |
| Complexity for buyer | Higher (must arrange freight) | Lower (seller arranges freight) |
Cost Comparison: A Real Example
Here is a simplified cost comparison for a 20-foot container of ICUMSA 45 sugar (25 MT) shipped from Dar es Salaam to Rotterdam:
| Cost item | FOB to buyer | CIF to buyer |
|---|---|---|
| Product price (ex-vessel) | $X / MT | $X / MT |
| Ocean freight (Dar–Rotterdam) | Buyer arranges (~$2,000–$3,000) | Included in CIF price |
| Marine insurance | Buyer arranges (~0.3–0.5% of cargo value) | Minimum ICC-C included |
| Destination charges | Buyer pays | Buyer pays |
| Import clearance | Buyer pays | Buyer pays |
The CIF price will always be higher than the FOB price for the same cargo, because it includes freight and insurance costs. The total landed cost at your destination should be similar either way — the difference is who controls and pays for each element.
When to Choose FOB
FOB is generally preferred by experienced importers who:
- Have an established relationship with a freight forwarder
- Want full visibility and control over freight rates
- Are importing frequently and can negotiate better freight rates than the seller
- Want to choose their own insurance provider and coverage level
- Are comfortable managing the freight booking process
When to Choose CIF
CIF makes sense for buyers who:
- Are placing their first order and want simplicity
- Do not have an existing freight forwarder relationship
- Import infrequently and cannot easily compare freight rates
- Want a single all-in price to compare between competing suppliers
- Are buying from a supplier with strong freight relationships who can offer competitive CIF pricing
A Note on Insurance Under CIF
The insurance included in a CIF price is always the minimum — Institute Cargo Clauses (C), which covers major losses (sinking, fire, collision) but excludes many risks including water damage, condensation and theft. For agricultural commodities shipped over long distances, buyers should consider whether this minimum coverage is adequate and top it up with ICC (A) cover (which is all-risks) at their own expense. Your freight forwarder or insurance broker can advise on appropriate coverage for the commodity and route.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the risk really transfer at the same point under FOB and CIF?
Yes. Under both FOB and CIF (Incoterms 2020), risk transfers to the buyer when the goods are loaded onto the vessel at the named port of shipment. The difference is that under CIF, the seller has already paid for minimum insurance covering that risk during transit.
Can I use FOB if I don't have a freight forwarder?
You can, but you will need to arrange ocean freight yourself. We recommend establishing a relationship with a freight forwarder in your country who can quote and book freight on your behalf. Many freight forwarders handle the full import process including destination customs clearance.
Which Incoterm does Golden Seed Export offer?
We offer FOB Dar es Salaam as our standard term. CIF to your nominated discharge port is available on request. Please specify your preferred Incoterm when requesting a quote.
Ready to request a quote?
Tell us your preferred Incoterm — FOB or CIF — and we will include it in your quote. Respond with pricing within two business days.
Request a Quote →